Mechanical keyboards come in a few basic types, but all of them have sprung keys that move way more than the keys on a modern laptop. This springy movement, along with a positive click that lets you know when a keypress has been registered, make them very satisfying to use. I love them. I’ve owned or reviewed plenty of them, and I still keep a few under the couch. But I rarely dig them out anymore, because they’re just too painful.
What is a Mechanical Keyboard?
Picture a computer from the 1980s, or an electric typewriter like the IBM Selectric from the 1960s. They comprise a molded plastic keycap, with a switch underneath, and the best ones, or at least the noisiest ones, are the Cherry Blue switches. These switches are the whole point of a mechanical keyboard, because they provide a feel unlike that of any scissor-switch or butterfly keyboard, or those awful rubber-dome switches found inside really cheap keyboards. Those keycaps can also be pulled off and replaced. The switches aren’t moving (unless you have a special model where the switches are meant to be replaced), but the keycaps can be swapped. There’s a big market for custom keycaps, so you can really go to town and customize your keyboard.
Ergonomics
The keys take a little getting used to. The first few days can be frustrating. If you ever swapped your mouse or trackpad to your non-dominant hand, this feels the same. The discomfort is in the head, not the fingers. But persevere and it will seem quite comfortable. Or not. While some people prefer the increased finger movement of mechanical keys, others (like me) may find it uncomfortable after a while. It all depends on your own setup, and the state of your carpal tunnels. Mine aren’t happy with an extended use of clicky keys. But more pressing than the keys, themselves, are the ergonomics of the keyboard as a unit. I find they are, almost universally, too tall. Unlike a regular modern computer keyboard, which is only a few millimeters tall, the average mechanical model can tower well over an inch above the desk. Couple this with today’s desks, which are also a little high, and you have a recipe for RSI. Look at the stands that held old electric typewriters, and you’ll see how low they are compared to your desk. If your keyboard forces your forearms up to meet it, you should either add a keyboard tray under the desk, or saw a few inches off the desk’s legs. I opted for the latter, but it’s still too high with some keyboards.
Expensive Habit
The other downside of mechanical keyboards is they’re expensive. That’s no problem on its own, because a good keyboard will last decades, but they can be addicting, and you might find yourself with an expensive habit. Here’s an example. I’m using my trusty Filco Majestouch 2, which I really love. While writing, I decided to research the latest low-profile mechanical keyboards, and it sent me on a journey into expensive experimentation. If you write all day long, you owe it to your wrists to get a good keyboard, and to position it properly. That may be a mechanical model, but it might equally be a simple modern keyboard. Whatever you do, don’t use a mechanical keyboard if it’s uncomfortable, no matter how cool it looks.
